Signature opinions.

[johnxfire]

Signature opinions.

Hey guys, I'd just like your personal opinions on these two new signatures I had just made:

Thanks for your time!

 

[Constrictor]

Ok if you want easy opionion I can say they are pretty good.

For serious opinion (Skip of you don't want to read)

Main character (Subaru) is to blury. That's make him less important in your signature. Color theme blend together so that also make Subaru more less important. Best background color for light green object should be green too or red (maybe orange) light blue is good also.

The position where you place brushes and lines anre in good position. Good job.

You test XFire is to dark. Someone may miss the text too.

Again, you shold make your main character more important than background (Also text that color is to similar to background)

But the abstract background is nice. Compare to your sig right now. Your current signature is great example for text.

But is your signature style is blury I can't complain that

End of my opinion.

NVM you have rotating signatures. - -"

 

[celestial_sacred]

I agree with Constrictor. ^^

About the first one, I think it's okay to make Subaru blurry, EXCEPT for his face and a little around it.

 

[Tcatomon]

I really like the pegasus version.

The other.. I'd just back off the blur a hair, or ...maybe just do the edges around him and see how that looks?(like you did with pegasus). Otherwise I like. :'D

 

[Nabs]

i prefer the 2nd one then the first one and the colour of the text for both sigs dosen't really stand out-->i didn't see it until i read the 2nd post

 

[johnxfire]

Alright guys, thanks for the opinions!

I've fixed em up a bit:

Decided to remove the blur, it got annoying.
Feel free to comment, I'll be using them as rotating sigs once I finish my third sig.

 

[Tcatomon]

Much better! ^__^ You can tell it's a dragon in the first one now.. (I know near squat about Ryuusei, I thought it was just a green WarRock..thing oo; )

 

[AznxLoneWolf]

^ I agree. Much better than the first two .

 

[Constrictor]

Good job !

But the your second signature text is still to hard to read

 

[celestial_sacred]

Oh wow! Nice~ It looks better now! But I think both of the characters need to be a little bit brighter so they don't sink into the background.

But the your second signature text is still to hard to read

I think the "outstanding-ness" of the text depends on the artist. Maybe johnxfire doesn't really want "xfire" to be that noticeable. If he wants it, then it really needs more touch.

 

[johnxfire]

Maybe johnxfire doesn't really want "xfire" to be that noticeable.

Got that right. I don't really focus on the text, but I found it a bit messy anyways.

Thanks for your opinions, guys!

 

[Constrictor]

Oh wow! Nice~ It looks better now! But I think both of the characters need to be a little bit brighter so they don't sink into the background.



I think the "outstanding-ness" of the text depends on the artist. Maybe johnxfire doesn't really want "xfire" to be that noticeable. If he wants it, then it really needs more touch.

I mean text blend with background to much so I can't read it easy xD

 

[celestial_sacred]

I mean text blend with background to much so I can't read it easy xD

Oh! Sorry for misunderstanding. At least it's still readable.

 

[AznxLoneWolf]

I mean text blend with background to much so I can't read it easy xD

Personally, I think it's more of a font issue, not a color one...or am I just missing the point? ;

 

[johnxfire]

New one. I'm gonna make use of all three in another rotating sig.

 

[celestial_sacred]

Wow. That looks neat! The lighting's a bit normal but it's good enough to me. You really love that blurry effect, don't ya? Haha

 

[johnxfire]

Yep. I should really try some other styles, but I'm still not sure on how to use sorta advanced stuff like clip masks with .psd files.

 

[Constrictor]

Yep. I should really try some other styles, but I'm still not sure on how to use sorta advanced stuff like clip masks with .psd files.

You never know if you never try

 

[Tcatomon]

Clipping masks aren't really too hard if you play with them. (Of course I do them daily at work, lol ^^; )

 

[johnxfire]

Bumped this old topic up, for kicks.

I've got relatively new sigs for myself:

and my current signature.

...A bunch made for a few friends in another forum: