6th movie win/fail

Dash

I Ireland
Staff member
Supreme Dictator
6th movie win/fail

Warning/blah for Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince.

Win
The two big potion scenes. Love Potion & Felix. Total win. I don't think I laughed so hard in forever.

Fail
Horocrux explanation. Srsly, how is Harry gonna know he has to search for Founder items?

Bill/Fleur. They're kinda important for the 7th/8th movies.

Also
I saw Gabe <3 Hehe. Old crush \o/~


DISCUSS
 

Ryuuk

Shinigami
I haven't seen it yet but...

I heard Scrimgeour isn't even in it

that makes me kinda mad
 

Zodiac

Gurren Brigade Member
Ryuuk;97841 said:
I haven't seen it yet but...

I heard Scrimgeour isn't even in it

that makes me kinda mad

Yeah, that sucks.
Scrimgeour was a main plot device in 6. Not to mention he dies in 7. How could they do that...
 

Skr

Ishvalastrator
Staff member
Well, they've cast him for the 7th...
Wikipedia said:
In the film adaptation of Deathly Hallows, Scrimgeour will be played by Bill Nighy.
 

megumi

SPAM BOT
Staff member
WARNING WARNING
I'm going to wait a while before I go and watch it. >_> I don't even remember what happened in the 6th book. *read it more than 3 years ago and hasn't reread it*
 

Skr

Ishvalastrator
Staff member
Totally failed.
The total essence/point/whatever of the sixth book, to me, was to find out who Tom Riddle is. What his life was like, what kind of student he was... just about him. That then leads them to the horcruxes.

All this romance crap that the movie made the whole movie revolve around is pointless. Yes, it moved to the HarryxGinny and RonxHerminone, but we already all knew that.

There was little movement at all except for the last half of the movie. I laugh at the director's comment that they cut the memories/flashbacks for "greater stuff" (the romance stuff). The movie would have been specular if he just kept to the book. People don't read Harry Potter for the romance, they have Twilight for that.

fdfgdf I'm just totally disappointed with this movie. The Half-Blood Prince was already my least favorite book... and it has now become my least favorite movie. Worst adaption of the series yet. I seriously hope the director and producer got it together for the final movie. Part 1 is suppose to come out November of next year. With all the errors they made in the past movie, I really dread how it's gonna end up. They cut so much stuff... stuff that was important to the final book... Bill/Fleur where? New Minster where? (THE FIRST BLOOMIN CHAPTER OF HBP IS JUST ABOUT THE NEW MINISTER OF MAGIC. THE FIRST CHAPTER PEOPLE).

stupid movie. -could continue to ramble-
 
Top